The state's prosecutor, Michael Guerra, filed a motion on Monday, April 28, 2014 to consolidate the cases against Nancy and Omar. If the court grants the motion, Nancy and Omar the prosecution will be able to prosecute the two together, rather than separately, presumably saving them some of the considerable work that lies ahead in convincing a jury of their specious claims. Thus far, the District Attorney's office has failed on at least two counts: to provide a justification to county residents for its prosecution of the two and to convince a jury of either person's guilt.
On April 7, the state dismissed their earlier complaint of resisting arrest against Omar and later failed to convict him on the sole charge of obstructing a passageway. During the trial, the jury heard testimony from the arresting officer, his supervisor and Omar. The only other piece of evidence submitted in the state's prosecution was a photograph of the airport's empty interior, presumably taken after he and Nancy were arrested.
The arresting officer and his supervisor both testified, under cross-examination from defense lawyer Tom Kolker, that they decided on a reason for Omar's arrest only after holding a brief conference and dismissing multiple, other potential offenses. The arresting officer also testified that the two USBP agents that prohibited Nancy and Omar from proceeding to the Transportation Security Administration's pre-boarding screening had notified him that they planned to arrest Omar once their supervisor arrived. But, the arresting officer testified, his supervisor arrived first and together they began to discuss the possible rationale for removing Omar from the airport and taking him into custody. Omar, they confirmed, never used any part of his body to obstruct the free passage of people moving toward the TSA pre-boarding screening area. In fact, they testified that by the time they arrested Omar, the vast majority of the flight's passengers had already passed by the USBP agents and entered the TSA screening area.
Omar maintained that he never obstructed the free passage of people, consciously or as a matter of fact, testifying that while one agent continued to prohibit his own forward movement, the second agent proceeded to question the remaining passengers and wave them along to the TSA screening. His only intention, Omar maintained, was to defend what he believed was his constitutionally-guaranteed right to not answer the questions of the USBP agents, even while he recognized the federal agents' authority to ask their questions. Under cross-examination by prosecutor Jeremy SoRelle, Omar affirmed that, although he was born in Mexico, he does consider himself a proud American. When asked why, if he was a proud American, he still refused to answer the USBP agent's questions regarding his citizenship and immigration status, Omar answered that it was precisely because he was a proud American that he felt it was his responsibility to exercise his rights and his belief in the protections guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution.
Defense attorney Virginia Raymond asked jurors to compare Omar's encounter with the USBP agents in the Brownsville airport with one familiar to most: a disagreement between a customer and a store cashier over the amount of money paid and owed in a typical transaction. Imagining themselves as customers who firmly believe they have handed a cashier a $100-bill for a $47 purchase and received only $3 change in return, instead of $53, jurors agreed that they would not have left the cash register without first resolving the dispute, even if they were aware that their continued defense of their claim resulted in the blockage of the check-out aisle, and possibly the ire of fellow customers. The risk of being denied their due, they agreed, was too high for them to simply move on. It was worth their $50 to stand up for their beliefs. Comparing the supermarket scenario with Omar's encounter with the USBP agents, Raymond argued that one's belief in their constitutional rights is certainly worth more than $50.
What is worth to the state to proceed with their prosecution of two people who were arrested for exercising their belief in the U.S. Constitution's curbs on the federal government's intrusion into the lives of everyday citizens? What are the costs, financial and otherwise, incurred by the state's residents and tax-payers for a case with such questionable value? Whose interests is the District Attorney's office serving?
No comments:
Post a Comment